Ring Around the Rosie: Debunking Plague Myths
Could "Ring Around the Rosie" be a grim reminder of the 1665 plague, or is it just a playful children's rhyme with no dark undertones? Join me, Knob Twister, and my co-host, Sofa Sitter, as we unravel the tangled web of history, folklore, and linguistic twists behind this famous nursery rhyme. We challenge the widely accepted theory linking the rhyme to the Great Plague of London, dissecting symptoms, the supposed role of posies, and variations like the British version substituting "achoo" for "ashes." Our journey doesn't stop debunking myths; we reveal fascinating insights into the rhyme's historical and linguistic origins, shedding light on lesser-known interpretations and the true meaning of "posy."
But the fun doesn't end there! We also explore the many quirky versions of "Ring Around the Rosie" passed down through generations and cultures. From "a bottle full of posies" to the whimsically odd "husher, husher, cuckoo," we celebrate the rich tapestry of this timeless tune. We add a nostalgic, playful touch to our discussion by sharing our favorites and inviting you to do the same.
This episode is a replay from 2019-2021; please disregard any announcements during the episode.
The cover of L. Leslie Brooke's Ring O' Roses (1922) shows nursery rhyme characters performing the game.
In our latest podcast episode, "Ring Around the Rosie: Debunking Plague Myths," we dive deep into the history, folklore, and linguistic twists surrounding one of the most famous nursery rhymes.
This episode, hosted by Knob Twister and co-host Sofa Sitter, unravels the commonly accepted theories for "Ring Around the Rosie.” We also discuss some not-so-common theories.
Our journey begins with examining the popular belief that "Ring Around the Rosie" refers to the symptoms and events of the plague in England in 1665. The hosts dissect this theory, discussing the symptoms of the plague, the use of posies to combat the disease, and the interpretation of "falling down" as a curtsy rather than a reference to death.
They delve into the etymology of the word "posy," clarifying that it refers to a bundle of flowers or herbs rather than a specific type of flower. This information may debunk the idea that the rhyme has dark undertones related to the plague.
One of the most intriguing aspects of the episode is the exploration of the various versions of "Ring Around the Rosie" found across different cultures and generations. The hosts highlight whimsical endings like "a bottle full of posies" and "husher, husher, cuckoo,.”
American children playing the game, an illustration by Jessie Willcox Smith from The Little Mother Goose (1912).
The hosts also delve into alternative theories about the origins of "Ring Around the Rosie." One such theory suggests that the rhyme originated to circumvent the religious ban on dancing among Protestants in the 19th century. This theory posits that adolescents used ring games as a substitute for square dances, disguising their dancing as playful games. This idea adds a fascinating layer to the rhyme's history, presenting it as a symbol of resistance and creativity.
In addition to debunking myths and exploring historical context, the episode celebrates the playful and joyful aspects of "Ring Around the Rosie." The hosts share their personal favorite versions of the rhyme and invite listeners to do the same.
The podcast also discusses more recent and less credible theories about the rhyme's origins. For instance, the hosts discuss a theory linking the rhyme to concentration camps during World War II, where prisoners supposedly used blood to draw circles on their faces to appear healthier. This theory is debunked due to the historical timeline, as the rhyme predates World War II by several centuries. The hosts address this and other outlandish theories, emphasizing the importance of critical thinking and historical accuracy.
The episode is a delightful blend of history, myth-busting, and heartwarming nostalgia. It also celebrates the playful and joyful aspects of the rhyme, encouraging listeners to share their favorite versions and connect with the timeless tradition of nursery rhymes.
